When Can a Single Argument Lead to a Domestic Violence Charge?

Can a single argument with your partner actually result in a domestic violence charge here in Mineola, NY? It can, though it typically doesn’t. There usually needs to be more than just an argument with words, but you’ll need to talk to a domestic violence attorney to understand and protect your rights.

New York and Domestic Violence

New York does not treat domestic violence as its own separate crime. Instead, it looks at certain acts that happen between family or household members to see if they qualify as family offenses under state law. 

Who Counts as “Family?”

Family is defined broadly for the purposes of these laws and covers all current and former intimate partners, all blood relatives, any people who are living together currently, and anyone who shares a child in common.

When Does Behavior During an Argument Cross into a Family Offense?

A plain verbal disagreement rarely leads to charges on its own, but if the argument includes actions that fit specific Penal Law violations, then a domestic violence charge can be applied.

Disorderly Conduct

Disorderly conduct is one of the most common ways a heated argument could end up being a domestic violence charge. Under Penal Law 240.20, you can face this charge for engaging in violent, tumultuous, or threatening behavior or for making unreasonable noise that serves no legitimate purpose. 

Harrassment

Harassment in the second degree often comes up in these situations, too. This is defined as striking, shoving, or subjecting someone to physical contact with the intent to harass, annoy, or alarm them. It also applies if you attempt or threaten such contact. This means just a single push or a direct threat to hurt someone, made during an argument, can meet the standard. No serious injury is needed.

Menacing

Menacing can be a charge if you intentionally place or try to place your partner in reasonable fear that you’re going to physically injure them. This can happen through words combined with gestures or if you raise your voice to such a degree that the other person believes harm is coming.

Assault

Assault charges require more than words. A third-degree assault charge can be applied if you cause physical injury, even if it is only pain from a slap or grab during the argument. If the contact leaves a mark or causes pain that a reasonable person would feel, it can support a charge.

How a Domestic Violence Attorney Can Help

Defending these cases starts with looking closely at exactly what happened during that argument. Did the words or actions truly meet the legal requirements to be called what they are? Was self-defense involved? Was the report exaggerated or false? 

Evidence like text messages, witness statements from neighbors, or even recordings can make a big difference, and every detail matters. Your lawyer knows what to look for and how to use it for your defence.

If you have been charged with DV after a single argument, contact the Law Firm of Michael R. Franzese in Mineola or Central Islip today for help.

Posted in Uncategorized | No Comments »